• Banner 1
  • Banner 2
  • Banner 3

Welcome to Augies Prime Italian Steakhouse

Augies Prime Italian Steakhouse, located in Mohegan Lake, NY, offers a delightful blend of Italian, steakhouse, and seafood cuisines. With a diverse menu featuring vegetarian options and a variety of dining utilities, Augies caters to all preferences. Customer reviews rave about the perfectly cooked dishes, excellent service, and inviting ambiance. Highlights include the Salmon Piccata, Ribeye, Prime Rib, and the must-try bacon appetizer. The welcoming staff and cozy atmosphere make every visit memorable. Whether it's a special occasion or a casual dining experience, Augies Prime Italian Steakhouse is a top choice for a delicious, classy meal.

Augies Prime Italian Steakhouse: Reviews & Ratings

Alex H.
Alex H.

WOW! My graduation party at Augie's Prime Italian Steakhouse was amazing!! The food was excellent!! The Salmon piccata was perfectly cooked, the Ribeye and Prime Rib were delicious and the bacon appetizer- O M G ! The service was excellent!! Nobody was without a drink at any time! Ren was the best bartender- makes a phenomenal martini! We weren't rushed once our reserved time had ended! Truly a fantastic experience! I would recommend Augie's to anyone looking to have a classy, well run, fun filled party!

Michael M.
Michael M.

I haven't been to this restaurant in a while they have not Missed a beat We were there twice this week food service and ambience were amazing we were there for their 15 year anniversary special everything on the menu was $15 cannot wait to go back to doing 50% off lunches starting next week the owners were there and greeted us and remembered us. They are so hands-on. Matt took good care of us and Liz. The bartender was fabulous. Haven't seen her in a long time. It was so great. Going back to Augies cannot wait to go again.

Maria D.
Maria D.

Just took advantage of the 15th anniversary special at Augies 2 nights! Had the salmon piccata and chicken martini, everything was delicious!! Service was on point we will be back for sure. Looking forward to spring and summer on the patio!

Samantha F.
Samantha F.

Love the new Augies Prime Italian spin! I've always loved the restaurant, so this new addition is even better. They still have all the popular steaks and my favorite shrimp cocktail. As an Italian food lover, the home made pasta additions makes the place even better. It's still the same great staff and fun ambiance. Make sure not to forget to order the zeppoles for desert!!!

Jacinta L.
Jacinta L.

I love the food at Augies. It's consistently amazing. The staff is so friendly and accommodating. I was there recently on cold night and it made me appreciate the warm ambiance even more.

Stephanie F.
Stephanie F.

Always a Wonderful Welcoming dining experience! Consistently a Great Place for Dinner,Lunch, Or Chat at the Bar! Has daily happy hours snack specials to indulge before your ready to sit down to phenomenal meal & decadence desserts you could d*e & go to Heaven from!!!

Jerome S.
Jerome S.

Great food , great service , the bar can get a bit busy during happy hour but the main restaurant usually has room.

Sophie S.
Sophie S.

An out of town adventure, came here for a celebration. The 4 of us ordered our drinks off of their special seasonal drink menu they provided. I don't remember the names of the drinks other than some of the details an apple bourbon, sangria, pumpkin martini, & I'm not sure what the last one was. The drinks we ordered were great, we each enjoyed them with our meals. For the dinner, everyone pretty much ordered the steak cooked medium or medium rare. I'm not a steak person but I tried a piece of it and it was actually tasty and flavorful. The sides were an additional charge when they ordered their steaks. I had the chicken marsala which had mashed potatoes underneath. The chicken was super easy to cut and melts in your mouth. The mashed potatoes paired wonderfully with it as well. Overall, we were all pretty happy with our dinner selections and left with a belly full and happy. We were seated pretty quickly and had an overall good experience for our first time visiting.

Emily Q.
Emily Q.

Went home to celebrate the holidays with the family and we decided to go out to Augie's one of the nights. We went rather early around 3:30pm so it was super easy to get a table and the parking was plentiful in the back. The wait staff was very nice and pleasant to deal with. As we walked in there is also an outside area that is covered and heated for sports fans and casually drinkers. We started out with drinks and bread and both very good. Each member of my party got some form of steak (as one does as a steak house) and nobody had any complaints. The meat was tender and cooked very well. I personally got the searing steak with my partner and it came out sizzling (it stayed so hot that it was still sizzling and splattering a little bit) The sides were hit or miss personally the mashed potatoes were a little dry for my personal taste and the creamed spinach was a little lacking, but nonetheless still good. Last we got desserts, each had its own charm after being shown to us on a large platter. Again no complaints. One fun surprise that we got was that since we came before 5:30pm our bill was 1/2 off, so a meal that should have been a little more expensive became cheaper (always nice!). One of our members had a gift card but wasn't allowed to use it because apparently you can only use certain color cards (I'm assuming it related to amount) during that time. Unfortunate but still worked out. Overall nice time, will stop back when in town and want a fancy meal with the family!

Location

Augies Prime Italian Steakhouse is a fine dining establishment located in Mohegan Lake, NY, that combines the best of Italian cuisine with prime steaks and seafood options. With a myriad of amenities such as takeout, delivery, and catering services, Augies offers a versatile dining experience for all occasions. The restaurant prides itself on providing a casual yet classy atmosphere, perfect for intimate dinners or lively group gatherings.

One standout feature of Augies Prime Italian Steakhouse is their diverse menu, which includes many vegetarian options alongside traditional steakhouse favorites. Customers rave about the perfectly cooked Salmon Piccata, mouth-watering Ribeye, prime Rib, and delectable shrimp cocktail. The bacon appetizer and homemade pasta dishes are also highly recommended by patrons.

The reviews from satisfied customers speak volumes about the superior service at Augies. From attentive waitstaff to skilled bartenders crafting delicious martinis, every detail is meticulously taken care of to ensure a memorable dining experience. The owners are known for their hands-on approach, greeting guests personally and ensuring that every visit is exceptional.

Whether you're celebrating a special occasion or simply looking for a satisfying meal, Augies Prime Italian Steakhouse is sure to impress. The warm ambiance, friendly staff, and outstanding cuisine make it a top choice for both locals and visitors alike. Don't forget to save room for dessert and indulge in their famous zeppoles for a sweet finish to your meal. Visit Augies Prime Italian Steakhouse for a dining experience that will exceed your expectations.